Juarez is not a cadaver. Dreamland at EPMA

Lubbock artist Alice Leora Briggs’ Dreamland: The Way out of Juarez, which opened Sunday at the El Paso Museum of Art, leaves me extremely conflicted.
Obviously  talented and extremely dedicated she uses a version of the ancient technique of sgraffito technique to explore her themes. In this case, she cuts white marks into black surfaces to depict contemporary themes which look like something from the Middle Ages.
Traditionally, Sgraffito, which originated in the 16th century, was used either to decorate external walls or ceramics and seems to have been  most often used to expose different colors or to create a design in one color with an exposed contrasting color underneath.  Briggs works exclusively in black and white. and her work seems more closely aligned to Northern European woodcuts, which it resembles, though with contemporary themes.
Here she has focused on Juarez and the horrendous violence which has recently attracted world-wide attention. She visited morgues, rehab centers which had been scenes of  massacres, and other  centers of death. She has accurately captured details including local newspaper headlines, accurately depicting real events like pigs head masks placed on bodies, and decapitated heads. but all in a  richly detailed style which makes the contemporary look like some medieval scenario. In some cases, bodies are wearing medieval furs  or corpses are cut open like some ancient medical display. This might be Durer visits Juarez.
There are also a series of “stamps” in which she has also evoked the violence here and linked it to global commerce, often in witty ways. These horrifying scenes are all extremely well done and beautifully rendered.

She is obviously exploring more universal themes of violence and death, globalization, past and present, among other things. The work is quite brilliantly done.
So where does the conflict come from? For the last year or so, Juarez has become a favorite hunring ground for worldwide press. Everyone from the BBC to El Jezeera has come and dutifully reported the violence and the horrors; El Pasoans are continually reminded of why nobody should ever step foot in ultra-dangerous Juarez
We who live here are beginning to feel like some cadaver being pored over by medical students and doctors. We feel like a patient spread out etherized upon a table (to appropriate the old poet), and frankly we are all sick of it. We are sick of people coming in from outside reporting on the most obvious and the most sensational. Everyone reports on the violence, and while we are glad that people are paying attention, we are tired of being portrayed as a city in which there is nothing but gunfire, kidnapping and extortion, important as those things have become to life here, The situation is far more complex and requires far more subtlety. One rather wishes someone would try to understand the essence of Juarez.
A number of Brigg’s works include pig images and some anti-police graffiti. This might have been a literal rendering of something she saw, but as an exploration, the situation requires much more subtlety. This work is  going to be released as a book by UT press. It will include text by Charles Bowden, whose over heated prose also tends to  make one cringe.
Obviously Briggs is a serious and dedicated artist, and equally obviously she is using the violence in Juarez as metaphor or as an aid in creating a more universal portrait linking present and past, among other themes. But this city is something more than suitable subject to be used and exploited as a metaphor. It should not perhaps make a difference that she is from somewhere else or that most of the work displayed comes courtesy of The Box gallery in Santa Fe, but it does.

Most of the University artists here no longer deal with the violence here partly because they are tired of how everyone else in the world has made Juarez an object of horror, and partly because everyone is trying to explore his or her own artistic themes and trying to live as normal a life as possible despite a difficult situation.
If Briggs is fascinated with death and violence, then perhaps she should explore the violence of the drunks running over people on the streets of Santa Fe  or the crazies who burst into fast food restaurants or schools and blast away at everyone in sight. there is plenty of violence across the US to make tons of work.
If people are going to come here then one asks they really try to understand why Juarenses love Juarez, that they really understand not only the complex play of forces going on, but the richly complex life of people here, of the way in which Juarenses try as best as possible to live life as normally possible, why despite everything going on people still laught they still live they still go out and smilke at each other. Juarez is not a cadaver; it is not a subject for metaphor.-david sokolec

Advertisements
Posted in art. 5 Comments »

5 Responses to “Juarez is not a cadaver. Dreamland at EPMA”

  1. Carlos Says:

    Maybe I am very narrow minded but I think artist should deal (don’t have to but…) with things they know. It is just very easy to just jump on the vanwagon like everybody else covering and making things dealing with Juarez. Yes I can see artist in the border making this kind of art, it affects boths sides of the border and has become part of our daily lives. But to some one that does not live here or just visits Juarez for a few days and reads the newspapers to do art about Juarez or even write a book, is doesn’t make sense. There should be a new movement “The artist and writers that don’t live near the border, don’t know the border and don’t fucking care about the border, doing work about the border movement”!

    Like

  2. Katherine Brennand Says:

    Excellent, David…Your comments are truly insightful, sensitive and well expressed. And, Carlos, I totally agree; however, it would be a universal miracle indeed if people stopped painting, writing and talking about things about which they are completely ignorant. It’s an unfortunate aspect of the human condition.

    Like

  3. matt Says:

    Misty and I saw this exhibit a few days ago. We were struck by the raw and vivid way that Briggs has captured our city. But I agree with you, this is a complex situation and what is written about and documented in the media is gravely imbalanced. There is so much life happening here, far beyond the death and violence, and it is barely mentioned in the media or otherwise.

    Juarez is full of good people, loving people, families and children untainted by the mess around them. Thank you for your powerful words, David.

    Standing with you.

    Like

  4. monica Says:

    Please review the interview of the author, he is the opposite of a sensational reporter, in fact he is not a reporter.
    http://www.onthemedia.org/transcripts/2010/06/04/06
    Maybe you have money and education, and you can afford to overlook all the innocent lives that have been lost. Goya was arrested for his prints, many like yourselves didn’t approve of them, finding them to be offensive and full of false imagery.. It is the responsibility of the artist to be the voice of the voiceless. Reporters are the voice of politicians, and government officials. Please, open your eyes, and mind. And listen to this simple interview On The Media, with the author himself. Then do your critique.

    Like

    • david sokolec Says:

      Thank you for calling attention to this interview. As it happens I live by choice in Juarez, In no way do I overlook what is happening, and this interview does nothing to alter my feelings about Mr Bowden’s writings. By the way, Alice Briggs is going to be giving a lecture at the Museum on Saturday, June 19 at 2 pm to be followed by a booksigning.

      Like


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: